Plastic bottle caps can only be recycled if you screw them back on empty plastic bottles. If they go in loose in the recycling bin, they are too small to make it through the recycling process and end up in the trash pile.
Do not recycle lids — their shape, flat, makes them likely to get sorted mechanically with flat paper and contaminate the paper bales.
Subscribe to any of our Sustainable Bainbridge newsletters here. There is a general monthly newsletter that compiles articles submitted by the various SB programs and campaigns. There are also newsletters specific to certain programs.